TIME Magazine’s Controversial Cover

Next week’s issue of TIME is causing quiet a stir…the cover features a woman breastfeeding her son.

Now, perhaps that in and of itself shouldn’t be too brow-raising…I personally believe we’re far too squeamish when it comes to such a natural, normal, important thing such as a mother nourishing and bonding with her child, HOWEVER…the child pictured on the cover with his mom is three years old.

The article discusses “Attachment Parenting”, a method highly endorsed by Dr. Bill Sears, which suggests creating strong bonds between mother (and father) and child, de-bunking the spoiling myth that babies can get too much attention during their first year. Sears talks about the dangers of the cry-it-out method, Baby Wise theories, and other strict schedule-oriented routines that purposefully separate mother and child in order to promote independence. Sears believes-and has research to prove-that these theories only work to create feelings of insecurity, making the child more dependent and needy than an attachment-raised child.

“A child must go through a stage of healthy dependence in order to later become securely independent,” Sears states.

Attachment parenting encourages bonding through co-sleeping, baby-wearing, and prolonged breastfeeding.

When my firstborn was around 6 months old, I felt like I was at my wit’s end. He still wasn’t sleeping through the night, he sometimes nursed every 45 minutes, and wanted to be held constantly. I was given many books by well-intentioned family members and friends encouraging me to “put him on a schedule” for his own good. But despite my efforts, and the pit I had in my stomach every time I tried letting him cry, or prolonging his feedings because it wasn’t the right “time”, those methods didn’t take. And they didn’t feel right.

Then I discovered “The Sleep Book” by Dr. Sears. I remember feeling totally at peace after reading it. I felt like I wasn’t a bad parent-in fact, I felt empowered knowing my gut instincts were right about how I felt I was to raise my child. I agreed with much of what he said, and we co-slept with both our kids for several months when they were newly born. It was easier to breast-feed, easier to sleep, and a much easier way to cope with those early morning feedings.

I know Sears is considered somewhat of a controversial doc. Some of his philosophies are not popular or mainstream.

As this TIME article proves, prolonged breastfeeding falls under the “extreme” category, creating a huge rift between people who see the cover and celebrate, and people who see it and are repulsed.

I’m not sure how I feel. I nursed both my boys for 15 months. Around that time, I felt physically and mentally done, and decided to wean. But I know women who nurse until two or later, and they have perfectly happy, healthy, well-developed children. I don’t think I could go past the 15-18 month mark, personally, but do I think it’s “wrong” to breastfeed toddlers longer than that? No. I’d be uncomfortable nursing my three-year-old who is reading and writing and potty-trained and talking a million miles a minute, but I don’t think it should be controversial. It’s a personal decision.

If you want to learn more about Dr. Sears or Attachment Parenting (AP) go to askdrsears.com and click on “Attachment Parenting.” Check out next week’s edition of TIME.

And mommies…what do YOU think about AP-or this issue of TIME in general? How and when did you make the decision to stop nursing?

2 comments

  1. zoya

    When pregnant for the first time, I thought I would nurse for 3 months like everyone else I knew, for some bonding and then either pump or switch to formula(which I mistakenly had thought was as good, if not better than breast milk). When I learned that breast milk better nutritionally and immunologically, after getting an earful from a male pediatrician that who said the APA recommends nursing until a baby is at least 2 years of age(I had snorted out loud in the class). Well, after that informative earful(“…there are literally hundreds of components of breast milk science has not yet identified, much less replicated…”) I decided to try for 6 months. Then, after then initial difficult few weeks, we got to 6 months and I decided I could keep going until 12 months and then I’d see. By the time she turned one, nursing was such a part of our lives, I decided I could go until 2 and when we got there, I figured she would just wean when she was ready. Well, it turns out that was beyond age 3. I never would have thought that I would be nursing a potty trained, singing, talking, coloring child, but, somehow, when I saw the positives and benefits, it made sense. Even my husband who was wierded out by nursing so long, initially, told me he wished I would keep going, after she had pretty much weaned herself. I told him that, at this point, it didn’t feel right to push her to nurse. We sure loved the immunity benefits, especially when she started preschool.

    Still, seeing that cover photo made me laugh. Something about the photo itself is more of a statement than of how snuggly my kiddo was when she would nurse.

  2. Cat

    I made the decision to stop nursing when I would attempt to feed my child for 20 min on each side (as directed by the lactation specialist) and then give my baby a bottle. After 3 weeks of this futile effort, my baby was drinking 2-3 oz of formula and I was crying every time I had to nurse her. Both of us were much happier when we gave up the nursing thing. BTw – I was dried up within a day or two. I’ve had that simiar experience with 4 children. One child that I managed to successfully nurse, decided at 4 months that he didn’t want to do it anymore. He just wanted the bottle. I made him go to 6 months, but after that, I gave up. He wasn’t happy.

    I’ve read a bit about Dr Sears. I figure if it works for someone than great for them. I couldn’t cosleep. My kids are very active and I hate getting kicked in the ribs all night long. I think that despite my lack of following Dr Sears and just doing my own thing, that my kids are as well adjusted as any kids are.

Leave a comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.

*