Are you a Kate Gosselin or a Kendra Wilkinson?

The moment you become a mother, everything changes.

A few hours after giving birth to my first son, I placed him in the little bassinet (I felt terrible making him lay in something so sterile and hard but was desperate for some sleep) and laid my head back on the hospital bed.

Five minutes later, I heard choking sounds. I sat up as quickly as I could and tried to lift my son up and over the plastic bumpers with shaky arms. He was perfectly fine, just a little spit up stuck in his throat.

But I was not.

I held my tiny little baby and cried. I cried because I was exhausted. I cried because I realized that my life would never, ever be the same.

I cried because I was scared.

Motherhood is full of scary moments. Moments where you wonder, “Am I doing everything I should be? Are my kids going to be OK? Am I raising them the right way?”

Kate Gosselin and her eight children, from left: Joel, Collin, Madelyn, Aaden, Cara, Leah, Alexis and Hannah on “Celebrity Wife Swap” (Photo: ABC)

ABC’s “Celebrity Wife Swap” recently featured reality TV moms: Kate Gosselin and Kendra Wilkinson. These women are polar opposites. In fact, the only thing these two seem to have in common is the fact that they are both mothers. OK, and blondes.

I was super skeptical watching this episode. After all, Kate isn’t technically a wife anymore.

But I was really surprised with how much these women actually learned from each other.

In Kate’s household, everyone and everything is on a strict schedule. Like, down to the minute. But with eight kids, I think running a tight ship is necessary. Kate doesn’t have a full-time babysitter, housekeeper or cook. It’s all her.

Kendra, on the other hand, has a nanny who cooks and cleans. Her amazing saint of a husband, NFL wide receiver Hank Baskett III, picks up most of the slack, letting Kendra “relax” and get massages, go to hot yoga classes and have crazy nights out on the town.

When these two women swapped places for one week, it was like moving to a different planet.

“They’re mothering me!” Kendra exclaimed of Kate’s eight kids. “This has honestly been the hardest day of my life,” she said after a long day of making breakfast, lunches, doing laundry, cleaning the house and taking care of eight kids. “I don’t know how she does it every day.”

“Crazy,” Kate kept saying when she was repeatedly told by Hank to take it easy. Her first few days consisted of lying by the pool, golfing and having girls nights on the town. “This kind of life is luxurious,” she said, “but honestly if I had all this free time, I’d be spending it with little Hank.”

Halfway through the week, these women were allowed to change up the household rules and implement some of their own mothering styles. Kate had Kendra’s 2-year-old doing “chores” (putting away his toys, eating at the dinner table) and Kendra threw the schedule out the door and took all eight kids to a family fun center.

After the week, the two women got together to talk about what they learned.

Kate said she would take more time for herself, without feeling guilty. Kendra decided to start having family dinners and cutting back on the time little Hank spends in school so she could be with him more.

Neither woman was portrayed in a negative light. Neither lifestyle was favored. I started to think about how I mother my own children. I frequently compare myself to others, especially when I’m on Facebook or Pintrest too much. I don’t do crafts as much as I want to. I don’t make homemade bread on a daily basis. I am always wondering how much time is “enough” to spend one-on-one with each child, and do the others feel neglected? Do I write too much? Are they bored when I’m nursing (which is all the time)? Am I fixing the right foods for their growing bodies?

Kate is an excellent homemaker. But does that automatically make her an excellent mother?

Kendra is so laid back and care-free. But does that mean she’s happier?

I think, like most things in life, motherhood is balancing act. Right now, I feel like I’m mostly falling off the wire, but the point is I keep trying no matter how many times I fall.

Something Kendra said made me think hard about who I am as a person:

“I will never shut off any door to who I am.”

I think becoming a mother automatically means shutting off some doors. It should change you. It should make you a different person. But it should all be for the better and for the benefit of the child you decided to bring into the world.

Because behind every late night, early morning, messy kitchen, cluttered family room, and sticky, eight-passenger van there are three pairs of big blue eyes, thirty tiny toes, and six chubby cheeks who changed it all for me.

My three boys have opened a world a possibilities for me as a mother, and person.

And worth every scary, exhausting, joyful moment.



  1. Lillian H.

    Nice article Carmen. There is one bit that disturbs me enough to comment which I don’t usually do. You state that you compare yourself to other mothers and it seems that quite a few other moms and moms-to-be are comparing themselves to Kate Gosselin since CWS. Over the past few years and most recently on this show, Kate has stated that she does everything on her own without help from anyone. This statement is false as she stated at her new blogging job recently that “A month or so ago, I lost my long standing part-time cleaning lady to a full-time office job!” (full article can be found here – Now I’m not saying that she can’t or shouldn’t have a cleaning lady or any other help. Heck, I’m single and if I could afford it, I’d get a cleaning lady in a heartbeat! My concern is that there are mothers such as yourself who see Kate on shows like CWS with a house where Kendra could lick the floors because it’s so clean and think that they aren’t very good mothers because she has 8 kids and you only have 3 and yet her house looks like a show home while yours looks like a tornado hit it (not saying your house is messy!). Her house looked like that because she, by her own admission, had a part time cleaning lady. She said so in her own words on a blog she was hired to write. But she didn’t say that on the show, she said that she did everything herself so everyone watching thinks she really did. And some moms are probably beating themselves up because they can’t do what she does and they only have one kid. Now, maybe Kate is a super woman but she’s not a truthful one and anyone comparing themselves to her and thinking less of themselves might want to have all the facts first.

  2. Irene

    For crying out loud….these two moms got paid to be on tv (wonder how much the kids earned in a salary? if proper permits and contracts were taken out)

    Most importantly…Kate doesn’t have help is the biggest crock of monkey munch….does the Kate PR machine think if they lie about it enough people will just think she does parenting all on her own???? Secondly this is a woman who until TLC fired her spent more time AWAY from her children then raising them (go check APRIL 2009 gone 20+ days out of a month courtesy of TLC)

    Oh…….the truth is Kate Gosselin makes a mockery of motherhood….in fact at least Kendra being honest about her life makes a person feel for her bunny past…..whats Kate’s excuse???? “oh, I was my children’s pimp so I could have a tv career”

  3. Mona

    Did anyone mention that Kendra works? She has 2 shows. Did that factor into her daily schedule on the show? She may have been on hiatus when this was filmed, but it seems she is busier in her regular life than she let on.

  4. Anne D.

    Well, since you ask, I guess I’m more of a Kendra: like her and contraty to Kate Gosselin, I’m not a SAHM, I work during the day! Kate… well… hasn’t had a job for the last year and a half. And, by her own admission, has a part-time cleaning lady, a “laundry girl”, a tutor who comes to the house to help with the school homework, pool boys, lawn boys and, according to her diary found by Robert Hoffman, a cook who comes and deliver “homecook” meals to be frozen and served at Kate’s convenience. On top of that, her kids are gone to school for nine hours each day of the week.
    And, if I might add, motherhood is not really supposed to change you: it makes you “become”… In other words, the same Carmen as before her kids’ arrival should always be there… Probably more attentive to others, more caring, more reflective, more responsible, but still Carmen. If you were fun and carefree before having your babies, you should still be fun and carefree, but with all the added qualities that motherhood brings to a woman as long as she is open to the changes…

Leave a Reply to Anne D. Cancel reply encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.